In the newspaper, it says that…中的 it 是不必要的吗

《薄冰高级英语语法》上有这样一句：

In the newspaper, it says that the concert was cancelled. 报上说音乐会取消了。 (it 不必要，应改为 The newspaper says that the concert was cancelled.)

我不明白为什么这样用的 it 是不必要的。请老师解释一下，谢谢！

我个人觉得《薄冰高级英语语法》的这个说法值得商榷。我觉得以下三种表达都可以，且没意义上没有太大的区别：

The newspaper says that the concert was cancelled. 报上说音乐会取消了。

In the newspaper, it says that the concert was cancelled. 报上说音乐会取消了。

It says in the newspaper that the concert was cancelled. 报上说音乐会取消了。

陈根花 - 华文出版传媒执行主编

擅长：英语考试 | 采纳率 81% | 回答于 1秒前

默认排序时间排序

其它 1 个回答

曾克辉 1秒前

擅长：英语考试

同意陈老师的观点。介词短语in the newspaper在句子中是状语。类似的例句还有：

(1) It says on the packet that these crisps contain no additives. 包装上说这些炸薯片不含添加剂。《简明英汉词典》

= On the packet, it says that these crisps contain no additives.

(2) It says in the paper that they've found the man who did it. 报纸上说，他们已经找到了做这件事的人。《剑桥高级英语词典》

= In the paper, it says that they've found the man who did it.