10 with sth to do 是with复合结构还是普通的介词短语(不定式作定语)

看到前面有个网友提的一个问题:

https://www.cpsenglish.com/question/57108

With a lot of problems to settle, the president is having a hard time.

请问这里的 With a lot of problems to settle with 复合结构(不定式为宾语补语)还是普通的介词短语(不定式作定语,修饰前面的名词)?

对于一个普通的 with sth to短语,如何判断它是 with 复合结构(不定式为宾语补语)还是普通的介词短语(不定式作定语,修饰前面的名词)?有什么标准和方法吗?

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2022-05-21 11:18

@曹老师,您好!我在夸克《语法大全》第965-966找到了以下内容:

attachments-2022-04-kzMD5iLU625810e4bcb56.pngattachments-2022-04-aynCtbYr625810ed687c7.png

好像夸克认为下面句子中的With so many essays to write 是无动词分句,而不是介词短语,说明是把其中的不定式 to write 看作宾补而非定语:

With so many essays to write, I won’t have time to go out tonight.

请问这如何理解?我想听听大咖曹老师的看法。谢谢您!

请先 登录 后评论

其它 8 个回答

阿诺舒华辛力加

金标准就是:with后的名词或宾格代词必须作“+”后面的【名词/代词/形容词/副词/介词短语/现在分词/过去分词/不定式】的逻辑主语。

请先 登录 后评论
胡德忠  
擅长:英语

这个问题有点意思,我查了一下《英语介词用法词典》(强增吉, 张月祥编著),它也是把这样的结构看作 with 复合结构:

attachments-2022-04-HXKbxz0n625676e8c7fd4.jpg

希望看到专家老师的的分析!期待!

请先 登录 后评论
李万呼
擅长:教育

With a lot of problems to settle中的to do 语法书上一般当作后置定语处理,个人认为with复合结构后不定时理解为宾补和定语都可以,区别不大,因为用法一致,with后的宾语和to do 不定式为动宾关系,都为主动表被动。

请先 登录 后评论
曹荣禄  
擅长:动词用法,句法问题
请先 登录 后评论
每小时5o刀

看了原链接,先站个队,个人赞同黎老师的解答。我觉得,对于本站资深网友来说,这个问题不是问题了吧?


problems to settle这种不定式结构在《剑桥英语语法》中称为悬空(反射)不定式(hollow infinitive,即不定式短语中的及物动词或动词短语后不跟宾语,呈悬空状态,而这个宾语可以在前面找到,这句中settle的宾语是 problems。既然题干中的with短语中不定式和名词间是动宾关系,二者不构成介词宾语和宾语补足语关系,所以是不定式作定语。再者,这个with短语中不定式的逻辑主语是the president(补全的话: With a lot of problems for the president/him/her to settle)而不是problems


with独立结构中,除了极少数情况下being必须加上,大多数情况下逻辑主语后的being可省可不省,无being的未必是with复合结构,但有being的一定是with复合结构,即“with+宾语+现在分词 being”复合结构。如果这句话中的with短语变为With a lot of problems being to settle,那么自然就是with复合结构了。比如前几天在知乎上看到的这句:Code-named "Operation Overlord”, it was the largest combined sea, air and land operation in history, the aim being to free north-west Europe from German occupation. The aim 前可以加with

请先 登录 后评论
siwei

我觉得如果是:

With a lot of problems to be settled, the president is having a hard time.

或者:with a lot of problems showing up, the president is having a hard time.

那就更像是宾补

而如果是to settle,就更像是定语

请先 登录 后评论
alex119   - 工程师
擅长:英语

其实把框架搭清楚就很好理解这个问题的实质是什么。


1.With a lot of problems to settle, the president is having a hard time.


这里的with结构是否是带介词+不定式的独立主格结构?可以这么说:带介词with的不定式结构通常都不会理解成独立主格结构,网友为什么会理解成独立主格结构我觉得可能是某种臆想的产物。值得注意的是历史上“不带介词的独立主格结构确实可以有不定式存在的”。这种结构现在很少见了,在古英语和在爱尔兰比较常见。这个说法可以参考Curme的著作“Syntax(A grammar of the English Language v3)”第154页:


In older English, and sometimes still, we find the prepositional infinitive used here as predicate: ‘ I send you today three fourths of the sum agreed upon between us, the rest to follow within a month.’


In popular Irish, the infinitive has come into wide use here, so that it can be employed in every kind of subordinate clause, in conditional clauses, tem poral clauses, etc.: (conditional clause) ‘ It would not be for honor she to go without that much’ (Lady G regory, McDonough’s Wife).

如果With a lot of problems to settle改成With a lot of problems settled就是带介词with的独立主格结构,但是意义不同,同主句the president is having a hard time意思也不匹配。


既然不理解成独立主格结构,那要如何理解?大家都已经说的很多了,我提一个理解思路,可以琢磨琢磨:


With a lot of problems to settle和With a lot of problems to be settled的区别在哪?这个问题又回到不定式作后修饰时表主谓关系和动宾关系时的区别是什么?一般动宾关系绝大多数情况下表情态意义,暗含动作还未发生。而主谓关系(被动也是主谓关系)一般不表示情态意义,具体什么意义只能根据上下文来判断。举几个这样的例子看看:

2.With the new methods still to be tried it cannot be said what results may be obtained. [Since the new methods are still to be tried...].

3.With every desire to be methodical, I am going to find it difficult to subdivide my subject tidily and compactly.

4.With a number of seats still to be announced, they are certain to have at least six seats over the 218 required for an absolute majority.(Present-day English syntax第221页)

5.With increasing overheads to be met, dividends are bound to take a tumble.(英语习语大词典)

6.With the practicalities of the EU-Turkey deal still to be finalised - including the politically unpopular lifting of visarestrictions - more than three dozen people were killed by a car bomb in Ankara, the latest in a wave of attacks.(卫报20160315)

7.With more than half the delegates yet to be chosen and a calendar that favors us in the weeks and months to come, we remain confident that our campaign is on a path to win the nomination.(卫报20160317)

8.With outstanding technical and regulatory issues yet to be resolved, commercial delivery drones are not expected to become commonplace in our skies any time soon.(卫报20160727)
也就是说,如果写为:With a lot of problems still/yet to be settled, the president is having a hard time.肯定是可以的,有still和yet这些明显标志可以让句意更加明确。
请先 登录 后评论
陈才   - 英语教师
擅长:中考英语,词法问题

With a lot of problems to settle, the president is having a hard time.

解答:关于with+名词+其它 的结构中,如果“名词+其它”属于“宾语+宾补”结构,那么就是with的复合结构,反之,则不是with的复合结构,而且是其它形式的结构。然后我们再回过来看以上结构with a lot of problems to settle,很显然a lot of problems to settle这个结构中的“a lot of problems” 和"to settle"不具备“宾语+宾补”特点,所以不可以分析为复合结构。而是一个不定式to settle作后置定语,修饰名词a lot of problems结构

1with a lot of problems to settle 为介词with+名词构成介词短语作原因状语。不定式逻辑主语时后面句子主语 the president。

备注(1):如果不定式to settle逻辑主语是句子主语president,则不定式用主动结构“to settle”作定语修饰前面名词problems。

备注(2):如果不定式to settle逻辑主语是不是句子主语president,则不定式用被动结构“to be settled”作定语修饰前面名词problems。

【2I have a lot of work to do ,(a lot of work to do和上面结构一样,都是名词+不定式作后置定语)

备注(1):如果不定式to do逻辑主语是句子主语I,则不定式用主动结构“to do”作定语修饰前面名词work。

备注(2):如果不定式to do逻辑主语是不是句子主语I,则不定式用被动结构“to be done”作定语修饰前面名词work。

(1)I have a lot of work to do.(自己来做很多工作)

(2)I have a lot of work to be done.(委托别人来做很多工作)


请先 登录 后评论
  • 15 关注
  • 9 收藏,4573 浏览
  • 米佳佳   提出于 2022-04-13 12:42