8 Though failed, the man would not give in.(为什么不用Though being failed )

______, the man would not give in.

A. Though had been failed

B. Though having been failed

C. Though failed       

D. Though being failed

老师们好!

关于这道题目中fail一词,我有两种理解,但无法自洽,恳请老师给与指导!

 

理解1

failed形容词讲,此时相当于状语从句though he was failed 省略了he was

如果按照这种理解,我个人认为D选项中 Though being failedbeing为系动词的现在分词形式,应该也说得通啊?

还是说我忽略了什么不合理的细节呢?

 

理解2

fail 作“无能为力”讲时,为及物动词,可以有被动语态。那么failed就为动词fail的过去分词形式,表示被动。

(此处我理解此动词为静态动词表示无能为力的这种状态,不知是否正确)

但同时也无法解释为什么不能选B having been failed ,或D being failed(是否因为静态动词表示状态,无需时间先后的变化)

 

这个问题在网络上包括本站均没有找到说服自己的解释。故此麻烦各位老师帮助学生解惑!不胜感激!

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2022-03-28 15:32

这个题出的不合适。四个选项都是语法错误。如果把failed分析为形容词,则failed作为形容词只能作前置定语,不能作表语。如果把failed分析为谓语动词,则though从句单独省略主语而保留谓语动词,是不符合语法的。所以这个题没有正确答案。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 3 个回答

好题  
擅长:英语

这道题答案选C,正确,在你的这道题中,though failed = though it was failed, failed为过去动词(被动语态),如:He failed the exam. though failed的用法多见于书面语。

请看原文书籍中相关句子:

1.Horror film purists may object to the levity even though failed, as a lot of it is.

2. Tucker persuasively argues that Pickett's Charge, though failed in its execution, actually reveals Lee at his most masterful.

3. Various individuals in the pre-1970 Palestine who promised, though failed, to perform miraculous signs similar to those in the biblical tradition about the exodus and conquest.

请先 登录 后评论
Ethan999

1.不成立. 字典里讲了failed作形容词只能放在名词前。

2.此句有连词though,所以可以有两个谓语。也就是failedfail的过去式。省略了主语he

请先 登录 后评论
陈才   - 英语教师
擅长:中考英语,词法问题

Though (he was省略了 )failed, the man would not give in.

A. Though had been failed   B. Though having been failed   

C. Though failed       D. Though being failed

解答:以上是保留连词的过去分词作让步状语。分词作状语,其逻辑主语就是后面句子的主语。

Though failed, the man would not give in.

=Though he was failed , the man would not give in.

参考译文:虽然这个男人失败了,但是他不会认输/屈服。

1 fail   vt. 不及格 (英文解释If someone fails a test, examination, or course, they perform badly in it and do not reach the standard that is required.

I lived in fear of failing my end-of-term exams.  我总是担心期末考试不及格。

2fail   vt.评定不及格;使不及格(英文解释If someone fails you in a test, examination, or course, they judge that you have not reached a high enough standard in it.

They were the two men who had failed him during his first year of law school.  

他们是在法学院一年级时让他不及格的两个人

请先 登录 后评论
  • 7 关注
  • 2 收藏,2206 浏览
  • Lisbon22 提出于 2022-03-03 18:18