动名词和不定式含义辨析

Yesterday afternoon Frank Hawkins was telling me about his experiences as a young man. Before he retired, Frank was the head of a very large business company, but as a boy he used to work in a small shop. It was his job to repair bicycles and at that time he used to work fourteen hours a day. He saved money for years and in 1958 he bought a small workshop of his own. In his twenties Frank used to make spare parts for aeroplanes. At that time he had two helpers. In a few years the small workshop had become a large factory which employed seven hundred and twenty-eight people. Frank smiled when he remembered his hard early years and the long road to success. He was still smiling when the door opened and his wife came in. She wanted him to repair their grandson's bicycle!

1)  It was his job to repair bicycles - 为什么不是 It was his job repairing bicycles =  Repairing bicycles was his job. 理由是:动名词表示经常性,而不定式还有将要的,一次性的意思。

2)  Frank smiled when he remembered his hard early years. 我的分析和疑惑:when=after动作remembered先发生,然后再smiled我感觉根据课文语境,是否用进行时更好?即Frank smiled when he WAS REMEMBERING his hard early years 呢?

在回忆的过程中(过去进行时),smiled是否更合理呢 ?

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2022-02-18 09:47

1 动名词作主语较少使用外置结构。剑桥英语语法甚至认为 It is nice talking with you. 这样的句子中,talking with you是偏置结构,而不是外置主语。暂且不论这种观点是否被广泛接受,只是动名词短语作主语而外置相对于不定式作主语外置而言要少的多。尽管有的语法书认为不定式多表示具体一次性动作,动名词表示习惯或没有时间性的动作,但这并不是绝对的。不定式作主语其实也可以表示习惯性事件的。这个句子之所以用不定式作主语,主要原因是不定式处于外置主语的位置。如果不用外置结构,用不定式和动名词都是可以的。即Repairing bicycles was his job.或者His job was repairing bicycles.

2 remember有不同的意思,这里不是回忆的意思,而是想起( to cause (something) to come back into your mind)。句子意思是,当他想起...的时候,他笑了。即先想起,后微笑。没有理由把smiled改为was smiling。告诫:不要擅自改动原句!!!你的改动要么导致语法错误,要么篡改了作者的意图。这是很不好的习惯。你需要做的是去理解作者为什么不用进行时而用一般时,什么原因驱使作者这么做。然后你查词典remember的语义,你的水平就有所进步。如果你总是企图把句子改为你自己能理解的结构,你永远学不到新知识,你还曲解作者的意图。这种做法有百害而无一利!

请先 登录 后评论

其它 0 个回答

  • 2 关注
  • 1 收藏,1386 浏览
  • bjxue 提出于 2022-02-15 12:23

相似问题