定语从句省略疑问

This is a story about a boy making his dream come true through his own hard work.

This is a story about a boy who is making his dream come true through his own hard work.

不是做定语从句作主语从句不可以省略关系代词吗?


请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2020-09-29 15:23

This is a story about a boy making his dream come true through his own hard work.

【判断】这是一个结构和语义都正确的句子。
如果把making his dream come true through his own hard work 分析为现在分词作定语,则是语义错误的句子。因为这个故事写得太早了,“正在实现梦想的一个孩子”,这样的故事在全世界、在全国,甚至你的学校和社区里面,简直太多了。不需要去写。

只有把 a boy making his dream come true through his own hard work 分析为“动名词复合结构”,语义才允许。因为动名词意味着已经实现了自己的梦想,才需要大写而特写。就是说,动名词没有时间性,实现梦想可以早于这个故事。

This is a story about a boy who is making his dream come true through his own hard work.

【判断】这是一个结构正确、语义错误的句子。错误在于定语从句作定语,跟上面现在分词作定语的分析,同出一辙!

请先 登录 后评论

其它 2 个回答

曹荣禄  
擅长:动词用法,句法问题

This is a story about a boy making his dream come true through his own hard work.

划线部分为动名词复合结构作介词about的宾语。这里没有定语从句。

请先 登录 后评论
nashpeng

第一个句子是making引导的现在分词短语作后置定语;making与其逻辑主语a boy是主动关系;

第二个句子才是定语从句。

大多数情况下先行词作定语从句主语时,都可以作这样的简化,例如:

The man who was waiting for me has gone.

The man waiting for me has gone.

但表一次性动作或已经完成的动作时,多数要用定语从句而不用分词短语作后置定语。如:

The man who helped me yesterday is my uncle. (一次性)

Those who has finished the job may leave now. (已完成)

请先 登录 后评论
  • 0 关注
  • 1 收藏,1772 浏览
  • aaaaa123 提出于 2020-09-28 19:42

相似问题