1 have done/have been done的区别

What's the difference between "have been done " and "have done"?

The difference is whether active / passive.

======== ========

Let's first see the uses of “been” in English and then we can easily understand the difference here:

  1. Been is a Perfect State Form Maker.

  2. Been is a Perfect Continuous Maker.

  3. Been is a Perfect Passive maker.

Examples:

  1. have been busy all day with my project deadline. (State Form)

  2. have been waiting for your reply for a week now, man! (Perfect Continuous)

  3. Yay! I have been selected for the post!(Perfect Passive)

======== ========

OK, Now…

Your question:

Have Done vs Have Been done”.

here:

  1. “Have done” is persent perfect Active form.

  2. “Have been done” is persent perfect Passive form.

#Examples#:

  • have sent the documents to your email address.

  • The documents have been sent to your email address.


Hope it helps us to know the difference in a clear way!

Please feel free to comment and be generous enough to upvote as well!


一、按照上面的说法have been done可以表状态,延续以及被动三种用法,对吗?

二、在使用完成时的时候怎么能够判断出是状态,延续

比如“”我结婚了“” 怎么判断 不是I have married.而是I have been married.

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2020-02-18 16:38

网友的问题很尖锐。以下为我的判断:

1. I have married. (我结婚了。)

2. I have been married.(我结过婚。)


▲ 下面是我的具体分析。我认为,“我结婚了” 的表达可以是:

1. I got married.  

2. I have got married.  

3. I was married.

4. I married.

5. I have married.

“我结婚了” ,若只理解为一个“过去的动作”,其他不要考虑。这句汉语,本身没有提供足够的信息,例如不知目前的婚姻状态。所以,以上几种表达均可,但句4,句5 较少用主动,一般要有必具性状语。如:I married for love. I have married well.


▲ 关于 I have been married. 这句,married 用作形容词,表示“状态”,但由于本句没有时间状语(持续的时间),所以,这句话意味着:“结过婚,但已离婚,现在是单身”。原英文解答有一个缺陷是: 现在完成时用于 “系表结构” 表状态,漏掉了一个重要条件:必须跟持续的时间状语连用,例如 all day, for three years 等。没有这个时间状语,意味着婚姻状态“现已结束”。


▲ “我结婚了”的另外一个含义是:“我已结婚,而且一直保持婚姻状态”,则说: I am married.


▲ 现在,我把这7个句子放在一起,做个比较:

1. I got married.  

2. I have got married.  

3. I was married.

4. I married.

5. I have married.

(以上5句,只表示“已经结婚”,但目前婚姻状态不详。)

6. I have been married.(婚姻状态:离婚,现在是单身)

7. I am married.(婚姻状态:已婚)


请先 登录 后评论

其它 0 个回答

  • 1 关注
  • 1 收藏,15713 浏览
  • 刘江峰 提出于 2020-02-18 13:49

相似问题