6 疑问代词在特殊疑问句中的成分以及改成宾语从句的语序

下面都是我自己的一些想法。


Which is your book? which是疑问代词作主语。
Which book is yours? which 是疑问代词作定语, book 是主语。
What colour is your car? what 是疑问代词作定语,colour是主语。
What is your car’s colour? what 是表语。

Whose book is this? whose为定语,book为表语。


改为宾语从句(用陈述句语气)

I don't know which is your book.

I don't know which book is yours.

I don't know what colour your car is.

I don't know what your car's color is.

I don't know whose book this is.


上述两块哪里有误呢?

 我觉得主要是疑问代词who,whom,what,which,whose及其中心词所做的成分搞不清导致的。

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2018-08-22 11:30

主系表结构必须区别表语是归属性表语还是确认性表语。

Mary is a student. 归属性表语

Mary is my secretary. 确认性表语

确认性表语和主语为同一人或事物,因此在意义上相等,可以互换句法功能,即主语作表语,表语作主语。

Mary is my secretary.

My secretary is Mary.

因此,Which is my secretary?一句中,表语为确认性表语。因此这个问句可能是就主语提问,也可能是就表语提问。在问句中有歧义,只能根据上下文判断。如果改为名词性从句,则有二种可能:

He wants to know which is my secretary.

He wants to know which my secretary is.

没有上下文时,以上二句都是正确的。

归属性表语则不允许将主语和表语功能互换。

My car is red. What collar is your car? what collar只能是表语,不可能是主语。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

蒋学文   - 英语教师
擅长:英语

你的第一块有些对,有些不对,可改为:

Which is your book? which是疑问代词作表语

Which book is yours? which 是疑问代词作定语, book 是主语

What colour is your car? what 是疑问代词作定语,colour是表语

What is your car’s colour? what 是表语

Whose book is this? whose为定语,book为表语

 

你的以下宾语从句用法有些对,有些不对,可改为:

正:I don't know which your book is.  

正:I don't know which book is yours.

正:I don't know what colour your car is.

正:I don't know what your car's color is.

正:I don't know whose book this is.

请先 登录 后评论
  • 2 关注
  • 4 收藏,6129 浏览
  • stupid_02   提出于 2018-08-20 19:50

相似问题