2 complaints by sb的用法疑问(没有被动语态也可以用by表示“被”吗)

Complaints by the older generation about the different habits of the young and the life they lead can be found at least as far back as two and a half thousand years ago.

 

1.请问老师,以下句型分析的正确吗?

主语是 complaints by the older generation;介词短语 by the older generation 是complaints 的后置定语。其次,介词短语 about the different habits of the young and the life they lead 作主语 complaints by the older generation 的后置定语。谓语是can be found。时间状语是 at least as far back as two and a half thousand years ago。 句中 the life they lead 中 they 指的是 the older generation。

 

2. 为何是 complaints by the older generation 而不是 complaints made by the older generation ? 有无made有何区别?

谢谢老师。


请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2018-04-18 17:03

Complaints by the older generation about the different habits of the young and the life they lead can be found at least as far back as two and a half thousand years ago.

句子的主语是名词complaints,by介词短语和about介词短语分别都是主语的后置定语。the life they lead中的they指代the young, 不是the older generation. 句子的逻辑是老一代人抱怨年轻人的习惯和年轻人的生活(方式),而不是抱怨自己的生活方式。

网友对句子的其它分析是正确的。

一个动词作谓语时,动作施事者为主语,受事者为宾语,可能还会有状语。当这个动词变形后当作名词使用时,逻辑上仍有施事者、受事者和对动作的修饰语。此时动作的施事者通常由介词by引出,受事者由介词of引出,修饰语的介词通常不变。例如:

Police arrested Tom on Sunday. 主语+谓语+宾语+时间状语

The arrest of Tom by police on Sunday surprised everyone. 原来的主谓宾状结构变成了一个名词词组,由中心名词后接三个介词短语作后置定语,分别表示该名词所表示动作的受事者、施事者和时间状语,但在语法上,这三个介词短语不能叫主语、宾语和时间状语,他们都是名词arrest的定语。

因此,名词complaints的二个介词短语作定语,在逻辑意义上分别是抱怨这个动作的施事者和抱怨的内容,但在语法上是定语。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

刘永科   - 教育出版集团英语总顾问 & 英语系列图书主编
擅长:语法理论,语言学,文化背景

Complaints by the older generation about the different habits of the young and the life they lead can be found at least as far back as two and a half thousand years ago.

1.请问老师,以下句型分析的正确吗?

主语是 complaints by the older generation;介词短语 by the older generation 是complaints 的后置定语。其次,介词短语 about the different habits of the young and the life they lead 作主语 complaints by the older generation 的后置定语。谓语是can be found。时间状语是 at least as far back as two and a half thousand years ago。 句中 the life they lead 中 they 指的是 the older generation。

2. 为何是 complaints by the older generation 而不是 complaints made by the older generation ? 有无made有何区别?

【答】complaints by the older generation = complaints made by the older generation

介词by 引出动作的施事者,即行为主体,可以直接放在名词、动名词或具有动作的名词之后作定语,说明是由谁完成的。它实际是被动语态的简化形式,省去了相应的过去分词(made by the older generation),直接使用by 更简练。

例如:

books by Lun Xun = books written by Lun Xun (鲁迅写的书)

bombing by planes = bombing performed by planes (由飞机实施的轰炸)

At Smith she turned down a request(made)by students to have race-specific dorms.

在史密斯大学,她拒绝了学生提出的按种族分住公寓的要求。

They are trying to avert a strike (carried out) by the actors.

他们正设法要免除一场演员举行的罢工。

The city was thrown into turmoil because of a protest (held) by taxi drivers.

由于出租车司机的抗议使得该城市陷入了混乱。

 


请先 登录 后评论
  • 1 关注
  • 2 收藏,4703 浏览
  • 007li 提出于 2018-04-15 00:29

相似问题