1 So倒装形成的是主语补语还是表语

I felt as though I was split in two, so keen was my desire to follow her, and yet so deep was my longing for the woman whose spirit had truly companioned me and upheld my own.

 

1.书上是这么讲解这个句子的:

So 开头引起部分倒装, 其结构是“主语补语+系动词+其他”,请问老师,到底是“主语补语”还是“表语”?

 

2. as though引导的从句是非真实情况用作比喻,所以as though I was split in two是使用虚拟语气。正式用法是were,这里用was是非正式用法。


谢谢老师。

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2017-12-24 13:39

I felt as though I was split in two, so keen was my desire to follow her, and yet so deep was my longing for the woman whose spirit had truly companioned me and upheld my own.

1.书上是这么讲解这个句子的:

So 开头引起部分倒装, 其结构是“主语补语+系动词+其他”,请问老师,到底是“主语补语”还是“表语”?

你看到这本书采用的是现代语法体系。主系表结构中的表语(predicative)是传统语法的称呼,现代语法(如夸克和章振邦的书)中没有表语这个术语,将传统语法的表语分析为主语补语(subject complement)。但现代语法的主语补语的概念。

夸克将系词后的方位结构分析为状语。例如:

The book is on the desk.  主语+动词+状语

The book is interesting.  主语+动词+补语

以上二个句子在传统语法都分析为主语+系词+表语。

因此,这个句子中的so keen..., so deep其实就是传统语法的表语。

 

2. as though引导的从句是非真实情况用作比喻,所以as though I was split in two是使用虚拟语气。正式用法是were,这里用was是非正式用法。

as if=as though引导方式状语从句或表语从句。这种从句中的谓语形式分为三种情况。

1)早期英语as if/as though从句的谓语一律用虚拟语气。因为as if=as it would be if...

2 ) 现代用法中如果从句表示的是与事实相反的假设,从句用虚拟语气;如果有可能是事实,用陈述语气。

3)现代英语非正式语体有一种倾向:不论从句说的是否与事实相反,一律用陈述语气。

目前第2种用法最为普遍,即从句用虚拟语气还是陈述语气取决于从句表示的是明显与事实相反的假设,还是有可能是事实。前者用虚拟语气,后者用陈述语气。当需要用虚拟语气动词were的时候,如果主语是第一、三人称单数,用was代替were. 这时传统语法认为仍然是虚拟语气形式(现代语法认为不是了)。例如:

He feels as if/as though he were flying. 正式用法。虚拟语气。

He feels as if/as though he was flying. 非正式用法。传统语法认为是虚拟语气,现代语法认为是陈述语气的过去进行体表示与现在事实相反的假设。你的句子中就是这种用法。

He feels as if/as though he is flying. 非正式语法,被部分母语者使用。国内考试会认为是错误。例如下句:

The toy dog barks as if it is true. 玩具狗叫起来像真狗一样。(从句显然不是事实,但用陈述语气。)

补充内容

so/such位于句首时,传统语法书都认为句子必须部分倒装。但Cambridge Grammar认为部分倒装和完全倒装都可以,完全倒装主语用于主语较长,结构较为复杂的情况。只是前者更常见。需要注意的是如果主语是人称代词,指只能用部分倒装。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 3 个回答

陈才   - 英语教师
擅长:中考英语,词法问题

I felt as though I was split in two, so keen was my desire to follow her, and yet so deep was my longing for the woman whose spirit had truly companioned me and upheld my own.

1.书上是这么讲解这个句子的:

So 开头引起部分倒装, 其结构是“主语补语+系动词+其他”,请问老师,到底是“主语补语”还是“表语”?

2. as though引导的从句是非真实情况用作比喻,所以as though I was split in two是使用虚拟语气。正式用法是were,这里用was是非正式用法。

解答如下:

你的问题涉及到以so开头倒装的问题


在”so…that…”和”such…that…”引导的结果状语从句中,当so和such位于句首时,用”so\such + ... +部分谓语+ 主语+...”; 主句倒装, that从句不倒装:

so /such ……that句型可以构成部分倒装句,表示强调so /such和that之间的部分:

 

A:so+形容词+系动词(be)+主语+that

So angry was he (He so angry) that he couldn’t speak.

他如此愤怒,以致说不出话来。

So selfish was she that everyone avoid talking with her.

=She was so selfish that everyone avoid talking with her.

So difficult was the exam that most of the students failed to pass it.

=The exam was so difficult that most of the students failed to pass it.  

So easy is it that a child can learn it.

=It is so easy that a child can learn it.

So clever is he that he can work out all the difficult problems in the book.(全部倒装)

=He is so clever that he can work out all the difficult problems in the book.

So frightened was the girl that she daren't move an inch further.

=The girl was so frightened that she daren't move an inch further.

So small was the mark that I could hardly see it.

=The mark was small that I could hardly see it.

(备注:在该结构中,“so +形容词”是表语的前置;。)

B:so+副词+助动词(did/do/does)+主语+谓语+that

So hard did he work that he finally won the fame.

So hard does he work that he has made great progress in English.

So loudly did he speak that even people in the next room could hear him.

So quickly did the workmen finish their work that they were given a bonus.

So much does he worry about his financial position that he can’t sleep at night.

He runs so fast that he is far ahead of others.

=So fast does he run that he is far ahead of others.

备注:也存在such+be+主语的情况用以强调

Such was Albert Einstein, a simple man of great achievements.

阿尔伯特爱因斯是一个有伟大成就的普通人

Such was the force of the explosion that all the windows were broken.

爆炸的威力如此之大,以致所有的窗户都被震破了。


请先 登录 后评论
刘永科   - 教育出版集团英语总顾问 & 英语系列图书主编
擅长:语法理论,语言学,文化背景

I felt as though I was split in two, so keen was my desire to follow her, and yet so deep was my longing for the woman whose spirit had truly companioned me and upheld my own.

1. 书上是这么讲解这个句子的:

So 开头引起部分倒装, 其结构是“主语补语+系动词+其他”,请问老师,到底是“主语补语”还是“表语”?

2. as though引导的从句是非真实情况用作比喻,所以as though I was split in two是使用虚拟语气。正式用法是were,这里用was是非正式用法。

【答】

第一个问题:“主语补语”,也叫“主语补足语”,其实就是我们现在说的“表语”。国内有些人仍然沿用国外语法家的术语,把“表语”叫作“主语补语”。

有些国外语法家认为,句子除了主干部分(“主+谓+宾”)外,其他成分都是辅助成分,次要成分。主、谓、宾都可以有自己的补语,以增加新意或补足其表意的残缺或不完整。因此,就有了以下所谓的补语:

主语补足语: subject complement

谓语补足语: predicate complement

宾语补足语: object complement

从他们给的定义和列举的例子来看:主语补足语,其实就是我们通常说的表语;谓语补足语,就是我们所说的状语;宾语补足语,跟我们现在的叫法基本一致。

第二个问题:I felt as though I was split in two. 像as if,as though 引导的从句,是否用虚拟语气,在很大程度上,取决于说话者的态度和看法。

就这个句子而言,was 跟felt 时态完全一致,所以不是虚拟语气,而是陈述语气。

若改为were 或had been 则是虚拟语气。


【几条重要规则】

对于as if 是否使用虚拟语气,可以这样下个结论:

(1)如果as if 从句所表达的内容可能是事实的时候,使用陈述语气。

(2)as if 从句明确地表示不是事实。在这种情况下,仍然可以使用陈述语气。就是说,当as if 从句可以明显地看出所表达的内容是非真实的时候,使用陈述语气或虚拟语气是没什么区别的。例如:

The toy dog barks as if it is a real one. 这只玩具狗叫起来就像它是一条真狗。(“玩具狗”,无论如何都不是真的,谁都能看得出来。即便用了陈述语气,也知道它是假的!)

He talks as if he has/had a potato in his mouth.(都意味着“他嘴里并没有真地含着一个土豆”。)

(3)如果as if 从句所表达的内容可能是,或可能不是事实的时候,这时,是否用虚拟语气,取决于说话者的态度。

鉴于此,以下表达都正确:

as though I was split in two (陈述语气)

as though I were split in two (虚拟语气)

as though I had been split in two (虚拟语气)


此外,关于倒装结构:so keen was + 主语, and yet so deep was + 主语

so keen 和so deep 是两个并列的表语,有各自的主语。表语和主语颠倒位置,不单是因为so而倒装,而是因为主语相对较长的缘故,为了平衡句子结构、避免头重脚轻而采用的修辞方法。

请先 登录 后评论
黎反修   - 英语翻译 (已退休)
擅长:数词用法,存在句,英语考试
  1. “主语补语”也叫做“表语”。

  2. 根据《牛津英语用法指南》第三版74.2节,在as though后面表示“不真实”的从句中,正式文体用 were ,非正式文体用 was 。

请先 登录 后评论
  • 0 关注
  • 4 收藏,6753 浏览
  • 007li 提出于 2017-12-03 02:23

相似问题