1 比较句省略的问题

请问老师:

she had since been rushing off to the library a little more often than was strictly necessary for somebody who had no homework to do.

加下划线的部分省略了什么主语?

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2017-12-01 14:00

She had since been rushing off to the library a little more often than was strictly necessary for somebody who had no homework to do.

加下划线的部分省略了什么主语?

【翻译】从那以后,她就一直跑图书馆,只是比那些没有作业的人需要去图书馆,经常一些而已。

【分析】这是一个含有比较结构的复合句。主句部分含有often 的比较级:a little more often,than was strictly necessary for somebody who had no homework to do 是比较从句。关于than 是从属连词还是关系代词,目前有争论。

1. 认为than 是从属连词,那么就是引导比较状语从句。这样的话,was strictly necessary 缺少主语;

2. 认为than 是关系代词,本身既表示“比...”的意思,又作了was strictly necessary 的主语。

我认为:实际上,从句中的主语不是省略,而是由than 充当了,这个主语是无法添加上的!

关于than在从句中作主语的例句:

The question is more complicated than appears on the surface.

这个问题比表面看上去要复杂得多。

He never says more than is necessary.

他从不多说没有必要的话。(他从不说废话)

He often eats more than is good for his health.

他常常吃的饭量多于对身体有益的量。

The family spent more than is prudent or necessary.

该家庭花钱过多,超过了必要的限度。

It is not wise to be wiser than is necessary.

聪明过了头,就是不聪明。

The man drank a little more than was good for him.

那个人酒喝得过了量。

Always do more than is required of you.

凡事永远要超要求完成。

He offered more information than is needed.

他提供了多余的信息。

 

 


请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

曹荣禄  
擅长:动词用法,句法问题

She had since been rushing off to the library a little more often than was strictly necessary for somebody who had no homework to do.

引导比较状语从句than是个比较副词或比较代词,要在从句中作主语、宾语、表语、或状语。这个句子中than作为比较副词就作了主语。从这个角度理解,从句就没有省略主语。因此这是一个完整的比较状语从句。

试比较下句:

He never eats more than is good for his health.

than在比较状语从句中作主语,than是个比较代词。

Nowadays more people want to live in the countrside than used to.

than作为比较代词在从句中作主语,从句省略了替代动词do.

网友可以读一下我以前写的一个短文,阅读的时候将文中的than作为关系代词、关系副词改为比较代词、比较副词。当时没有想好名称,借用了关系二字,现在认为应该是比较代词/副词。http://ask.yygrammar.com/q-23051.html


请先 登录 后评论
  • 0 关注
  • 1 收藏,4781 浏览
  • steamgear 提出于 2017-12-01 10:19

相似问题