2 引导定语从句的关系代词在从句中作表语的情况

1. who、which、that引导定语从句时都能在从句中作表语吗?

当作表语,先行词指人时who和that能相互替换吗?先行词指物时which和that能相互替换吗?


2. He is not such a fool as he looks.他并不像看起来那样傻。

为啥looks后面没有like呢?不应该是he looks like a fool么?

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2017-11-28 19:39

1、who、which、that引导定语从句时都能在从句中作表语吗?

当作表语,先行词指人时who和that能相互替换吗?先行词指物时which和that能相互替换吗?

这个问题,前面已有讨论和解答,你可参读。如有疑问可以在这里追问。真正理解这一问题,需要了解确认性表语和归属性表语。链接如下:

http://ask.yygrammar.com/q-25044.html

http://ask.yygrammar.com/q-25052.html

http://ask.yygrammar.com/q-25082.html


2、He is not such a fool as he looks.他并不像看起来那样傻。

为啥looks后面没有like呢?不应该是he looks like a fool么?

可以说He looks a fool. 也可以说He looks like a fool. 二句中的look都是系词,第一句是名词作表语。第二句是介词短语作表语。两句意思有差别。第二句说他像个傻瓜。但他不是傻瓜。第一句的意思是他的外在表象显示他是个傻瓜,实际是不是不知道。翻译为他看起来是个傻瓜。


请先 登录 后评论

其它 2 个回答

陈才   - 英语教师
擅长:中考英语,词法问题

as引导的限制性定语从句,且先行词有as,so, such, the same或者等词修饰,它在定语从句中作主语或宾语的。

Such people as have made great contributions to the world should be greatly respected.那些对

界做出巨大贡献的人应受到极大的尊重。(as作从句的主语)

You may take as many chairs as you need.

你需要多少椅子就拿走多少椅子。(as作need的宾语)

My parents have not so much money as I want.

我父母没有我需要的那么多钱。(as作want的宾语)

He made the same mistake as you made in the last exam.

在上次考试中,他犯了跟你相同的一个错误。(as作made的宾语)

Tom is not such an intelligent person as you think.

I want the same shirt as my friend bought yesterday .

Such people as have made great contributions to the world should be greatly respected.

特别备注(1):such.....that ...引导结果状语从句,在从句不作任何成分,such ...as as 引导定语从句, as 为关系代词在定语从句作主语,宾语成分.】

【特别注意】

【1】在so/such...that...引导的结果状语从句中,that不作任何成分,只起引导作用。要注意区别这两种不同的结构。

They had such a fierce dog that no one dared to go near their house.他们家有一条凶狗,没人敢靠近他们家。(that引导结果状语从句,在句中不作成分)

【2】the same后有时用that,它表示“同一个,就是那一个”的意思,即同类同物;而as则表示“与……一样”,但不是同一个,即同类异物

This is the same cell phone that I lost yesterday.

这就是我昨天丢的那部手机。

This is the same cell phone as I lost yesterday.

这是与我昨天丢的相同的一部手机。

They had such a fierce dog (that) no one dare to go near their house.(结果状语从句)

He is not such a person as you think .(定语从句)

They had such a fierce dog as I had never seen.(定语从句)

This is the same book that I lost yesterday .(同类同物)

这就是我昨天丢失的那一本书.

This is the same book as I lost yesterday (同类异物)

这与我昨天丢失的那本书一样.

I bought the same dictionary as you borrowed.(同一类的2本字典)

I met the same person that I saw yesterday.(同一个人)

We have found such materials as are used in their factory(定语从句)

These houses are sold at such a low price as people expected(定语从句)

He is not the same man as he was (定语从句)

【3】但是在抽象名词,同类事物没有绝对区别,因此as/that可以换用)

I have the same opinion as /that you have.


请先 登录 后评论
刘永科   - 教育出版集团英语总顾问 & 英语系列图书主编
擅长:语法理论,语言学,文化背景

就本句而言,look 后加不加like,意思一样。
He looks a fool. = He looks like a fool. 
两句都是“他像个傻瓜”,实际都不是。


请先 登录 后评论
  • 2 关注
  • 6 收藏,21512 浏览
  • 谢小刀 提出于 2017-11-25 20:21

相似问题