The machine is ________.
A. to redesign
B. to be redesigned
不定式作表语时,若意义是被动的,如何确定是主动式还是被动式?
The machine is ________.
A. to redesign
B. to be redesigned
本题应该填不定式的被动式。
The machine is to be redesigned.这机器将重新设计。
不定式作表语时,若意义是被动的,应该用不定式的被动式。
可能的例外是不定式to let, to rent, to blame。如:
The house is to let. 房屋出租。
The house is to rent. 这个房子要出租。
The boy is to blame. 这个男孩应该受到责备。
The machine is to be redesigned.
根据试题的选项设置,应该是按照“be动词后可接不定式分句”(例如Collins Cobuild English Usage的be词条7有类似的解释)来设计的。这个句子也可以换种方式解释: 把be to解释为情态习语,后接省略to的不定式,因为the machine与redesign在逻辑语意上构成被动关系,故而使用不定式的被动形式。试对比:
1) The machine should/must be redesigned.
2) The machine is going to be redesigned.
此外,关于be to的处理,查阅并阅读了一下外版材料,语法学者们的处理不尽相同。L.G.Alexander按照The use of 'am/is/are to处理;Collins Cobuild English Usage在be词条处理为“You sometimes use to-infinitives clauses after be"; Bas Aarts把be to处理为modal idiom,同时还采用了Rodney Huddleston的解释;Rodney Huddleston按照quasi-modal be解释;章振邦教授把be to解释为semi-auxiliary。当然,be to的术语名称和其用法相比,并不是那么重要。如果感兴趣的话,可以阅读以下材料:
1. L.G.Alexander的Longman English Grammar 9.48.1 The use of 'am/is/are'部分
2. Bas Aarts的Oxford Modern English Grammar 10.3.10 Modal idioms和10.3.10.3 BE[to]部分
3. Rodney Huddleston的The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language Quasi-modal be部分
4. Randolph Quirk的A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language 3.45 Modal Idioms: had better,etc,3.46 The meanings of the modal idioms(d)和4.47Concluding comments on constructions expressing future time部分
5. 章振邦《新编高级英语语法》6.1C半助动词部分
至于Huddleston所说的quasi-modal,Bas Aarts是这样解释的: The label 'quasi-modal' indicates that in spite of its one modal property(and its modal meaning) this be doesn't in fact qualify grammatically for inclusion in that class.