一、个人看法：
我不知道陈才老师说的【超出中国英语应试教育考试范围知识以下可能是正确的：a brief period lying】是根据什么标准判断的？你说的“中国英语应试教育考试范围知识”是根据什么来确定的？我建议没有明确依据不要随便下这样的结论，有时感觉你就是“中国英语应试教育考试范围知识”的标准制定者，动不动就说“超出中国考试的认知范围”，不知底细的网友，会以为你的话有多权威，其实这样是很害人的！
二、问题出处：
我从网上查了一下，网友的这个句子来自《新概念英语》第四册第19课（完整内容见后面所附），所以这个句子的正确性是不用怀疑的，也就是说 a brief period lying 的用法肯定是正确的。a brief period lying 是否超出了“中国英语应试教育考试的知识范围”？我不知道！也没有找到权威的依据！但我想问的是：你知道《新概念英语》在我国的影响有多大吗？下面的内容是我从网上找的：
三、补充例证：
为了印证《新概念英语》上这个用法的正确性，我还可以提供一本权威词典(《麦克米伦高阶英汉双解词典》)的例句：
四、一点说明：
所以我建议您为网友解答问题还是严谨一点，谦虚一点，多向曹老师、好题老师、凡哥老师等学习，错了就了，不要强找理由挽回面子，真没必要。其实，我对陈老师本人并没什么意见，但我确实不太认可陈老师的答题风格，同时也是为了维护网站的权威性，写了这些内容，不当之处请陈老师谅解，同时接受各位网友的批评！
五、出处附件：
附《新概念英语》第四册第19课内容（翻译也是网上找的）：
Lesson 19 The stuff of dreams 话说梦的本质
It is fairly clear that the sleeping period must have some function, and because there is so much of it the function would seem to be important. 很清楚，睡眠必然具有某种作用。睡眠占去那么多时间，所以其作用似乎还很重要。
Speculations about its nature have been going on for literally thousands of years, and one odd finding that makes the problem puzzling is that it looks very much as if sleeping is not simply a matter of giving the body a rest. 人们对睡眠作用的种种猜测，确实已有数千年之久。一项使人对这个问题感到困惑的奇怪的发现是，睡眠在很大程度似乎并不仅仅是为了使身体得到休息。
“Rest”, in terms of muscle relaxation and so on, can be achieved by a brief period lying, or even sitting down. “休息”，从使肌肉得到放松等方面来看，只要稍微躺一躺，甚至坐一坐就能达到。
The body’s tissues are self-repairing and self-restoring to a degree, and function best when more or less continuously active. 人体组织在一定程度上有自我修补和自我恢复的能力，有张有弛地连续活动时，其功能最佳。
In fact a basic amount of movement occurs during sleep which is specifically concerned with preventing muscle inactivity. 事实上，睡眠状态下仍有着基本的活动量，以防止肌肉活动停止。
If it is not a question of resting the body, then perhaps it is the brain that needs resting? 如果睡眠的功能不是在于使身体得到休息，那么也许是让大脑得以休息？
This might be a plausible hypothesis were it not for two factors. 若不是下面两点，这种假使似乎是有道理的。
First the electroencephalograph (which is simply a device for recording the electrical activity of the brain by attaching electrodes to the scalp) shows that while there is a change in the pattern of activity during sleep, there is no evidence that the total amount of activity is any less. 第一点，脑电图记录仪（不过是一种把电极接到头皮上记录脑电活动的仪器）显示，人在睡眠时大脑活动的方式有变化，但没有迹象表明，其活动总量有任何减少。
The second factor is more interesting and more fundamental. 第二点更有意思，也更重要。
Some years ago an American psychiatrist named William Dement published experiments dealing with the recording of eye-movements during sleep. 前些年，美国一位名叫威廉•德门特的精神病学者发表了一项实验报告，报告中记录了眼球在睡眠时的活动情况。
He showed that the average individual’s sleep cycle is punctuated with peculiar bursts of eye-movements, some drifting and slow, others jerky and rapid. 他指出，平常人的睡眠周期中不时伴有一阵阵奇怪的眼球队活动，这些活动有的飘忽而缓慢，有的急剧而快速。
People woken during these periods of eye-movements generally reported that they had been dreaming. 在眼球活动期间被叫醒的人都说自己在做梦。
When woken at other times they reported no dreams. 在其他时间叫醒他们，则说没有做梦。
If one group of people were disturbed from their eye-movement sleep for several nights on end, and another group were disturbed for an equal period of time but when they were not exhibiting eye-movements, the first group began to show some personality disorders while the others seemed more or less unaffected. 如果有两组人，一组人连续几夜在眼球队活动时被叫醒；另一组人也是连续几夜被叫醒，但是在眼球没活动时被叫醒的。结果，第一组人开始出现性格失常，而第二组人似乎没受什么影响。
The implications of all this were that it was not the disturbance of sleep that mattered, but the disturbance of dreaming. 这一切暗示我们：睡眠受到干忧没关系，而做梦受到干忧是有问题的。
