提供一点参考意见:
1. 对于这句话而言,is后面的是表语从句,用that和when都可以,关键是看句子的含义;如果用that,句子含义不符合逻辑,不能说moment是一件什么事情,可以改成The funny thing in the show is that the bad guy falls into a pile of wet cement.
2. 你提供的链接里面的the moment接that, 和这里是两码事,链接里的the moment that ...是一个时间状语从句,如
The moment (that) we saw the house, we knew we wanted to buy it.
而这里,moment是主语,when引导表语从句。