使用had been的含义

老师:

A young manwhile traveling through a desertcame across a spring of clear waterThe water was sweet

He filled his leather container so that he could bring some back to an elder who had been his teacher

After a four-day journeythe young man presented the water to the old man.

His teacher took a deep drinksmiled warmlyand thanked his student very much for the sweet water.

The young man went home with a happy heart

After the student leftthe teacher let another/otherstudent taste the water.  He spit it outsaying it was awfulApparentlyit was no longer fresh because of the old leather container

He asked his teacher"Sirthe water was awfulWhy did you pretend to like it"

The teacher replied"You tasted the waterI tasted the giftThe water was simply the container

for an act of kindness and loveNothing could be sweeter"

We understand this lesson best as/whenwe receive gifts of love from children

Whether it is a cheap pipe or a diamond necklacethe proper response is appreciationWe love the idea within the gift rather than the thing

1)答案是another, 可是other为什么不可以呢?答案是when, 可是as难道不可以吗?

2he could bring some back to an elder who had been his teacher. - 这里的had been暗示当时已经不是他的老师了吗?不然,为什么不用一般过去时was呢?很奇怪。

谢谢老师!

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2022-05-08 16:53

1 student为单数,another=an other, 后接单数名词。other 后接复数名词,不可以后接单数名词。除非有定冠词the,否则other不可以后接单数名词。

当时间从句谓语为静态动词表示状态,或从句表示习惯意义时,要用when,不用as。你这个句子是习惯意义,不是事件意义。

2 过去完成时就是告诉你,这位老者曾经是他的老师,现在不是了。但他还记着曾经的老师,有好东西不会忘记老师。要尊重作者的用词和使用时态的含义,不要自作主张,擅自改动。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 0 个回答

  • 1 关注
  • 1 收藏,1891 浏览
  • bjxue 提出于 2022-04-08 15:01

相似问题