刚看到网友来自高中英语新教材(人教版)必修一第1单元(p3)的一个问题,如下:
Tai’an, 18 June 2019. A group of high school students who are taking part in an international youth camp at Mount Tai are creating a(n)___________about China’s most famous mountain. The purpose of the camp is to _____________ Mount Tai by introducing it to young people in a fun and easy way. The students are making an app about Mount Tai and taking photos of the ___________ and stones. The volunteers also visit middle schools in the area in order to talk to local teenagers. Liu Bin, a member of the camp, says that he is __________ to help Mount Tai as people have done for more than 3,000 years.
见:https://www.cpsenglish.com/question/54128
我觉得加粗部分的句子认为“泰山是中国最有名的山”不符合事实,应该是“泰山是中国最有名的山之一”,即其中的 about China’s most famous mountain 应该是 about one of China’s most famous mountains。
中国是个多山的国家,名山名水一大遍,仅以“山”而言,就有安徽的黄山、江西的庐山、浙江的雁荡山,还有东岳泰山、南岳衡山、西岳华山、北岳恒山、中岳嵩山,还有武当山、齐云山、青城山、龙虎山;五台山、峨眉山、普陀山、九华山、雪窦山、昆仑山、终南山……
我没有在哪本官方的版本中查到“泰山是中国最有名的山”,特提出质疑,求教各位专家!谢谢!
我觉得网友的怀疑是有道理的。
句中的 China’s most famous mountain 改为 one of China’s most famous mountains 更合适,更符合事实。比较下面两句,显然是有区别的:
China is America’s biggest trading partners. 中国是美国最大的贸易伙伴。
China is one of America’s biggest trading partners. 中国是美国最大的贸易伙伴之一。
我在百度查了一下,下面是相关结果(当然这并不权威):