3 过去分词与现在分词作原因状语的区别

When his first book of fairy tales was published in 1835, Andersen didn't think it would be successful, but children read the stories and wanted more. So, encouraged by their interest, he began what we know today as his great work.

Being written in haste, the composition is full of mistakes.

1. encouraged by their interest / Being written in haste,过去分词与现在分词作原因状语的区别?

2. as his great workwhat的宾补,如何理解as的意思,“表作为”吗?

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2021-09-28 10:42

1. 这两个的区别是过去分词作原因状语通常不强调和谓语动词的动作同时发生的意味,一般是分词动作在先,主句产生的结果在后。现在分词经常强调正在进行的动作,但在有的语境中,可与过去分词作状语同义。

Being written in haste, the composition is full of mistakes. 这是出自中国语法书上的句子,很多外国人是不认同的,因为being written 表示书还在写作中,全句就不太合乎逻辑了。请看国外两个语法论坛对这句话的讨论:

WR: It’s not a good sentence. Presumably written is meant as an adjective, but it doesn’t come across that way. That use of being tends to imply that the composition might still be in the process of being written.

Being written in haste, the composition is full of mistakes.  ​(bad)

Having been written in haste, the composition is full of mistakes. (good)

The composition, [which was] written in haste, is full of mistakes. (good)

https://forum.wordreference.com/threads/being-written-in-haste%EF%BC%8Cthe-composition-is-full-of-mistakes.3622797/

Grammar Exchange:

I share Gustavo's view that the perfective construction ("Having been written in haste") is much better, even if Chinese grammarians don't hear it as being better. Here is a sentence in which "being written in haste" would work.

Being written in haste, the composition will doubtless be full of mistakes.

Notice that the sentence refers to something that is being written rather than to something that has already been written. 

https://thegrammarexchange.infopop.cc/topic/being-written-in-haste-the-composition-is-full-of-mistakes-from-a-grammar

2. as 在这里可以理解为:作为


请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

XME

楼上老师解释很到位!

同学很多时候不用纠结两者在做原因状语上的区别,应该是从其本质上进行区别。
1 分词(现在分词和过去分词)词性是adj,adv, 因此都可以做定语,状语和补语。
①现在分词表进行,伴随,主动
Being a student,I can't afford to get married.
②过去分词表完成,被动

 Encouraged by their interest, he began what we know today as his great work.
分词做状语,其实就是状语从句的省略。
省略的三大原则:重复,逻辑主语一样,不引起句子歧义
①As I am a student,I can't afford to get married.
 As he is encouraged by their interest, he began what we know today as his great work.


请先 登录 后评论
  • 2 关注
  • 1 收藏,2659 浏览
  • Eric198226 提出于 2021-09-26 20:08

相似问题