5 she must have been pleased and touched. 是对过去发生的事情的推测吗?

But after all when I look back upon that winter in Paris, my pleasantest recollection is of Dirk Stroeve. There was something very charming in his little household. He and his wife made a picture which the imagination gratefully dwelt upon, and the simplicity of his love for her had a deliberate grace. He remained absurd, but the sincerity of his passion excited one's sympathy. I could understand how his wife must feel for him, and I was glad that her affection was so tender. If she had any sense of humour, it must amuse her that he should place her on a pedestal and worship her with such an honest idolatry, but even while she laughed she must have been pleased and touched. He was the constant lover, and though she grew old, losing her rounded lines and her fair comeliness, to him she would certainly never alter. To him she would always be the loveliest woman in the world. There was a pleasing grace in the orderliness of their lives. They had but the studio, a bedroom, and a tiny kitchen. Mrs. Stroeve did all the housework herself; and while Dirk painted bad pictures, she went marketing, cooked the luncheon, sewed, occupied herself like a busy ant all the day; and in the evening sat in the studio, sewing again, while Dirk played music which I am sure was far beyond her comprehension. He played with taste, but with more feeling than was always justified, and into his music poured all his honest, sentimental, exuberant soul.

请教老师:

上面节选中, she must have been pleased and touched. 是对过去发生的事情的推测吧? 那么为什么只能理解成对过去发生过的事情的推测,而不能理解成虚拟语气(与过去事实相反的假设)呢? 

是不是因为这一句 If she had any sense of humour 用了一般过去时的陈述语气呢? 如果是改成 If she had had any sense of humour (虚拟语气)......那么,其后的she must have been pleased and touched.

就要理解成虚拟语气(与过去事实相反的假设)呢? 另外,顺便请教老师my pleasantest recollection is of Dirk Stroeve中is of的of这里是关于about的意思吗?  

还有,it must amuse her that he should place her on a pedestal 这里的should用法如何理解?

非常感谢!

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2021-02-23 17:22

你不注意基本概念,导致你基本功不扎实,分析句子结构时很简单的问题被你无限复杂化,影响你对句子意义的正确理解。虚拟语气表示与事实相反的假设或愿望或推论,这种虚拟语气又叫做过去时虚拟语气,即句子的谓语动词必须采用某种过去形式。must没有过去式,只有现在形式,怎么能用在虚拟语气中表示与事实相反的假设或推论呢。你看,一个虚拟语气的定义,就可以很轻松的排除must的任何所谓虚拟语气用法。must不用于虚拟语气。问题结束!!!多简单! that从句的should为推定式should,表示感情色彩。你已经见过这种句子。难道你每见一次都要问一次吗?下次再提重复的问题必须多加鲜花,否则你提问太随便了。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

zbr1016.

我觉得你不是基础差,而是不复习。你的虚拟语气的疑问又死灰复燃了,好像在一年前吧,你还有另外几个你,都在问虚拟语气的问题,当时好像弄清楚了的。

英语一定要读,把语法内化到感觉上面。很多人不相信这一点。总觉得语法是干货是死知识记清楚就完事儿了。

请先 登录 后评论
  • 2 关注
  • 2 收藏,1569 浏览
  • Pupil07 提出于 2021-02-06 13:42

相似问题