新概念英语第二册88课自己一处理解和一处疑问

Lesson 88 Trapped in a mine困在矿井里

  First listen and then answer the question.

  听录音,然后回答以下问题。

  Why is the rescue taking so long?

  Six men have been trapped in a mine for seventeen hours. If they are not brought to the surface soon they may lose their lives. However, rescue operations are proving difficult. If explosives are used, vibrations will cause the roof of the mine to collapse. Rescue workers are therefore drilling a hole on the north side of the mine. They intend to bring the men up in a special capsule. If there had not been a hard layer of rock beneath the soil, they would have completed the job in a few hours. As it is, they have been drilling for sixteen hours and they still have a long way to go. Meanwhile, a microphone, which was lowered into the mine two hours ago, has enabled the men to keep in touch with their closest relatives. Though they are running out of food and drink, the men are cheerful and confident that they will get out soon. They have been told that rescue operations are progressing smoothly. If they knew how difficult it was to drill through the hard rock, they would lose heart.

  6个人被困在矿井里已有17个小时了。如果不把他们尽快救到地面上来,他们就有可能丧生。然而,事实证明营救工作非常困难。如果用炸药爆破,震动会 引起矿顶塌落。因此,营救人员在矿井的北侧钻了一个洞。他们准备用一种特制的容器把这6个人救上来。如果不是因为土壤下面有一层坚硬的岩石,他们的营救工 作仅用几个小时就可以完成了。实际情况是,他们已连续钻了16个小时了,但离钻透还早着呢。与此同时,两个小时以前放下井去的一只麦克风使井下的人可以与 其亲属保持联系。虽然他们的食物和饮料都快消耗尽了,但这些人的心情很好,坚信他们很快就会出去。他们一直被告知营救工作进行得非常顺利。如果他们知道了 钻透那坚硬的岩石有多么困难,他们会丧失信心的。

参考《have been doing和have done 的区别》与《曹老师对四个问题的解答,我在温习是遇到的问题

中的原文:

“如果教英语是一个人临时的工作(即临时、短期的、预计会结束的习惯,则谈论这个习惯时就需要用进行体。I’m teaching English at a night school these days.”

“终结动词的完成体不可以和持续时间状语连用,除非该for短语按照目的状语理解(实际是终结动词导致的结果状态的持续时间,而该持续时间是主语预先计划或打算的。例如 He has gone to Beijing for 2 weeks.)。”

我的疑问1:why is the rescue taking so long?这里rescue是持续终结性动词,如果表示习惯意义可以进行时加持续时间比如I am running these days。可是这里表示的是事件意义我认为应该是why have the rescue been taking so long?

我的理解1: Six men have been trapped in a mine for seventeen hours.这里trap是短暂终结性动词,这里的用法是不是跟he has gone用法一致。这里表示的是掉入后的状态的持续时间


请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2021-01-12 18:05

你的疑问1 :rescue在这个句子里是名词,不是动词。谓语动词是take, 因为花时间、用时间、耗时间。这个take是持续性非终结动词。该动作有持续期,在动作未结束的时候,就用进行体。这是标准用法。

你的疑问2:has been trapped for some time, 为系表结构。系表结构表示的是状态,be为静态动词。一个状态持续到说话时多久了,用现在完成时+for时间状语是标准用法。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

王汝涛   - 英语教师
擅长:英语翻译,词法问题,英语考试

先回答你的疑问1: why is the rescue taking so long? 这句话不是文章里的,而是出题人加在文章前面的。用现在进行时,因为文章并没有描述到已经把他们救了出来。也就是说rescue没有结束,文章也无法说明搜救用了多久。如果文章描述了搜救的整个过程,直到把人救了出来,就可以用完成时了。

你的疑问2:关于短暂终结性动词的用法,你提到的Six men have been trapped in a mine for seventeen hours. 和he has gone 两句有相似之处,但又不同,因为第一句是完成时的被动语态,转变成了系表结构,经常可以用来描述事情发生后的状态。所谓短暂终结性动词是相对而言,要看语境。

请先 登录 后评论
  • 2 关注
  • 1 收藏,2082 浏览
  • hetaojiazi 提出于 2021-01-10 23:39