Every hour since I came has been most enjoyable.
On the day before we left home, there came a snowstorm.
The year after she had finished college she spent abroad.
薄冰《英语语法》第四版在定语从句中写道:since, before, after亦可用作表时间的关系副词,并列出上面三个句子。Since I came 和after She had finished...这两个不是时间状语从句吗?
你提的问题暂时没有老师回答,可能是你提的问题让人拿不定主意---你到底是想问什么:
1)你是想知道 since, before, after能不能引导定语从句?
答案当然是肯定的,关系副词引导的是定语从句,since, before, after 作为表时间的关系副词,当然可以引导定语从句;
2)还是想知道since,before,after 能不能用于表时间的关系副词?
既然国内语法权威薄老说可以,你要反驳,就要提出大量相反的例证。答疑网虽然也有专家质疑夸克、质疑朗文等,先不论质疑的对错,起码都列出了大量的例句来支撑自己的观点,这才能引出讨论。你不能只简单的说某权威的观点错了,而要其余老师来收集例证吧?哈哈。我只能说这三个副词像ago,ever,once,now,just,just now一样属于特殊的副词。至于如何特殊,可能不同的名家有不同的理解吧,反正我个人赞成薄老的观点;
3)抑或是你看不出since I came和after she had finished...在你的例句中分别是修饰名词hour和名词year?
这个应该不会看不出吧?
Every hour ...<---定从...has been most enjoyable.
The year ...<---定从... she spent abroad.
4) 或者是其它?