关于-ing分词分句与限定从属分句的转换关系的疑问?

关于-ing分词分句与限定从属分句的转换关系

(章振邦新编高级英语语法543页。)

例如:

1)

The girl singing in the hall is/was my cousin.

=who is /was singing

=who has/had sung

=who has/had been singing

可以改成=who sang (一般过去时)吗?

即The girl who sang in the hall is/was my cousin ?


2)I feel it to be a rare occasion, occurring as it does only once in many years.

= since it occurs

原句occurring as it does, 也可以将as it does去掉,直接说成occurring only once in many years 吧?


请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2020-07-26 16:55

1) The girl singing in the hall is/was my cousin.

=who is /was singing

=who has/had sung

=who has/had been singing

可以改成=who sang (一般过去时)吗?

即The girl who sang in the hall is/was my cousin ?

 

章振邦语法是分别对应的。即,改为定语从句后,用现在时间范畴的时态对应 is:

is singing, has sung, has been sung (从句)----------- is(主句)

用过去时间范畴的时态对应 was:

was singing,  had sung, had been sung (从句)----------- was(主句)

说明一下,章振邦教授也太节约笔墨和纸张了!为什么这么表达呢?让读者大费心思,而且导致误解!

我给他重新改写一下:

The girl singing in the hall is my cousin.

=who is singing

=who has sung

=who has been singing

The girl singing in the hall was my cousin.

=who was singing

=who had sung

=who had been singing

 

抛开原句,只看网友的句子:

The girl who sang in the hall is/was my cousin.

请问:is/was 都要吗?如果分别都要,我给你答案:

The girl who sang in the hall is my cousin. (正)

The girl who sang in the hall was my cousin. (误)

 

 

2) I feel it to be a rare occasion, occurring as it does only once in many years.

= since it occurs

原句occurring as it does, 也可以将as it does去掉,直接说成occurring only once in many years 吧?

as it does,as it did :是习语。它的结构实际就是表示方式,意为“in fact, actually”,这也是本义。前者跟现在时连用,后者跟过去时连用。因为它是有语义的,不可省略。原句等于:

I feel it to be a rare occasion, occurring as it does only once in many years.

I feel it to be a rare occasion, occurring actually only once in many years.

I feel it to be a rare occasion, since it occurs actually only once in many years.

说明,章振邦这个句子是描述分词转换从句的。你问的是习语as it does。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 0 个回答

  • 0 关注
  • 1 收藏,2352 浏览
  • Long2019 提出于 2020-07-23 18:06

相似问题