2 if是什么用法(if不是连词吗,是否有省略)

这里的if是什么用法?if不是连词吗?这里的句子是否有省略?

But more and more the Japanese are turning to the cultural-tradition defense,a blatant if clumsy attempt to portray themselves as the victim of cultural prejudice.

请先 登录 后评论

其它 2 个回答

曹荣禄  
擅长:动词用法,句法问题

网上搜到如下原文:

Slaughtering Whales As an Expression of National Culture

         
    Call me Insensitive .
    Call me anything you like , but it needs to be said and I'm going to say it : The Japanese whaling industry for using the "cultural tradition" argument as a justification for carring on its barbaric practice .
    As you read this , a Japanese fleet is scouring the Southern Ocean for whales , lots of them . After years of being restrained by international treaty to dilling a few whales under the flimsy pretext of "scientific research , " the fleet plans to cut loose this season . More than 2,000 whales are being "harvested ," including up to 50 humpbacks , a protected species that was hunted nearly to extinction by the mid-20th century .
    If you listen to the Japanese government and the whaling industry lobby it serves , whales are plentiful and , besides , whalers are merely exercising a cultural prerogative . Sure . It's kind of like origami or flower arranging , only you use an explosive charge packed into a harpoon tip .
    In playing the culture card , Japan joins Norway , another pro-whaling nation that would love to take its harpoons back to sea . If anything , the Norwegian augument is even weaker than Japan's .
    Of course , using the word "culture " is a smokescreen anyway . This isn't about culture . Like almost everythingelse in the world that stains the human spirit , this is about greed . 
    Whaling , as practiced by the nation-states , has always been a purely commercial venture . In the Age of Sail the industry grew out of economic necessity . When a whale was killed all of it was used --as food , as lamp oil , as lubricant . Whale-bone was used to make corset stays and scrimshaw . Blubber was used to make soap and cosmetics . A single whale --remember , we're talking about the largest animal on earth--could produce a lot of stuff and that meant a lot of money .
    But that was then . Excepting a few indigenous settlements here and there , where local hunting using traditional methods is still practiced , whale meat if no longer a dietary staple , and whale oil hasn't fueled any lamps in well over a century . There is no byproduct taken from a whale that can't be made or obtained by other means .
    In other words , any whale being killed in the open ocean today is being killed for absolutely no good reason at all . Whaling is an obsolete industry , serving no one , which only makes the cruelty of the killing that much more repulsive .
    Yet the Japanese have a large , modern whaling fleet tied up in  Shimonoseki , a port on the southern tip of Honshu , and they're determined to use it .
    The stated reason behind the intention of killing 50 humpbacks is to measure the whale's pregnancy rates as part of a larger study of the Antarctic ecosystem . Pure bilge water , an old salt might say .
    But more and more the Japanese are turning to the cultural-tradition defense , a blatant if clumsy attempt to portray themselves as the victims of cultural prejudice . That , too , is bilge water . This is no time for the world to cave in to some misguided sense of political correctness , Oh the contrary , pressure should be applied to stop . If Japan won't stop , a boysott of Japanese goods would not be unreasonable .  


所以,这个句子应该是没有问题的。

more and more在这里不是限定词,而是状语,= increasingly.

blatant: 公然的,明目张胆的

clumsy:拙劣的

if在此是让步连词=though

if clumsy为省略形式的插入分句,= even if it is clumsy。

原文大意:

但日本日益转向为其文化传统辩解,明目张胆地(尽管很拙劣)企图把自己描绘成文化偏见的受害者。

请先 登录 后评论
刘永科   - 教育出版集团英语总顾问 & 英语系列图书主编
擅长:语法理论,语言学,文化背景

But more and more the Japanese are turning to the cultural-tradition defense, a blatant if clumsy attempt to portray themselves as the victim of cultural prejudice.

网友查原句,并核实:

1. more and more the Japanese:the 是否多余?

2. a blatant if clumsy attempt:这里,blatant 和 clumsy 都是形容词,应该同时修饰 attempt。所以,if 是否用错。此位置应该是这三个并列连词之一:and, or, but。

请先 登录 后评论
  • 0 关注
  • 1 收藏,4675 浏览
  • 奶嘴CC 提出于 2020-03-06 14:36

相似问题