评注性状语使用疑惑(Judging from...与Judged by...)


Judging from what he said to me today, his mind's made up.

这里是否可以改用Judged by呢?

为什么?

还有一个问题,一直没搞懂,如果是评注性状语,例如judging from,judged by, judging by等,是不是可以随意用,无须考虑主动或被动?

另外,还有 to judge by [from] 的用法吗?和judging from(by), judged by 都是一样使用,不受限制吗?

麻烦专家老师能否详细归纳一下用法,主要是评注性状语ing或ed是否完全一样,不受限制?


请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2020-02-04 10:55

先看二个副词作评注性状语的例句,该例句表示评注性状语的二种不同类型:评论和注释。

Frankly,you are wrong. 状语表示说话人对句子的注释/解释

= When I say you are wrong, I am frank.  (形容词frank的逻辑主语是说话人)

Importantly,you should come on time. 状语表示说话人对句子内容的评论。

It is important that you should come on time. (形容词important的逻辑主语为说话人所说的句子)

现在看judging 和 judged 作评注性状语的区别:

Judging by her last letter, they are having a wonderful time.

= When I say they are having a wonderful time, I am judging by her last letter. (judging的逻辑主语是说话人。—— 表示说话人对句子的注释。)

Judged by the ordinary standards, he was reliable.

= It was judged by the ordinary standards that he was reliable. (judged的逻辑主语为he was reliable这个句子。——表示说话人对句子的评论。)

To judge from what he said, he was very disappointed.  (to judged的逻辑主语为说话人。——表示说话人对句子的注释。)

= Judging from what he said, he was very disappointed.

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

如沐春风


给网友查一些资料,供您体味。


用…衡童,从…看(judge多用分词形式)

➢ Judged by the ordinary standards, he was reliable. (Snow)

➢ Judged by immediate results the Chartists failed completely. (Hazen) 

➢ "Thirty years ago/he said/That's a lot of years judged by anybody's standards.  (CIH)

➢ Judging by the look on his face, he doesn't think much of our local wine. (CIE)

➢ I thought that, judging by the response of the audience, I had made an effective speech. (Pollitt)

➢ Judging by his testimonials, I think he will suit the post. (McMordie)


judge from从…看,根据…可以看出:

➢ From the finger marks high on the cupboard we can judge that he was a tall man. (CIE)

➢ To judge from the evidence of the experts, the deceased was still alive at three o'clock. (CIE)

➢ Judging from wha.t you say, he ought to succeed. (ALD)

➢ Judging from the number of cars, he thought, there were not many people at the club yet. (Greene)


以上例子出自 张道真《现代英语用法词典(重排本)》judge词条。


另外:《朗文高阶》有:

judging by / from sth, used to say that you are making a guess based on what you have just seen, heard, or learned

   依据〔所见、所闻或所学〕来判断:

   Judging by his jovial manner he must have enjoyed his meal.

   从他愉快的样子来看,他这顿饭肯定吃得很开心。

   Judging from what you say in your letter, you don't sound well.

   根据你来信中所写的情况,你听上去好像不大好。


      综上,大概可以得出这样的结论:

   1. judging.../to judge...的动作执行者,是说话人或写那句话的人,juding的结果就是主句所述内容。

   2. judged from...强调动作承认者是句子主语。比如Judged by the ordinary standards, he was reliable. (Snow) = If he was judged by the ordinary standards, he was reliable. (Snow) = If you judged him by  ordinary standards, (you could say)he was reliable. (Snow)  =Judging by the ordinary standards, he was reliable. (Snow) 

  3. 虽然有时候可以换,但未必“可以随意用”,主要看语境语义,还有就是语用习惯和语言接受度问题。因此,在考试时候,最好不要以身试法。


   希望以上回答对网友有用。

请先 登录 后评论
  • 2 关注
  • 3 收藏,20071 浏览
  • Long2019 提出于 2019-07-25 13:01

相似问题