关于 where 的代词用法

记得有 where 做代词的用法。如: 

Where are you from?

关于你去过哪里旅行的提问:

Where have you been (traveled) to?

Where have you been (traveled)?

该用哪种?


请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2019-08-25 19:45

where 作为副词,也可以做介词的宾语。所以很多词典并没有where 作为代词的词性。当然你把名词位置的where分析为代词也未尝不可。

have been to 为动态意义,约等于 visit.

Where have you been to? 意为,你都去过哪些地方?

Where have you been? 意为,你去哪儿了?(你一直在哪里呆着,我找都找不到你。)


请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

mengxin Z

这个来自The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language

应该是非常权威了:


Usage Note: When where is used to refer to a point of origin, the preposition from is required: Where did she come from? From where I sit, the situation looks bleak. When it is used to refer to a destination, the preposition to is generally superfluous: Where is she going (rather than<而不是> Where is she going to)? The place where they are going is beautiful. When it is used to refer to the location of a person, event, or structure, the use of at is widely regarded as regional or colloquial: Where is the station (not Where is the station at )? · Where is also used to mean “in which” as in Show me an example where government intervention in the market has worked. The Usage Panel, formerly dubious about this use of where, has come to accept it over the years. In our 2017 survey, 77 percent of the Panel accepted the example just given, and 81 percent accepted Sometimes the discussion degenerates into a situation where each person accuses the other of being illogical, a significant increase from the acceptance figures of 60 and 44 percent respectively for the same sentences in 2001. · Where is also used in instances where that might normally be expected, as in I don't see where they had much choice but to give up. The Usage Panel has less fondness for this usage. Only 49 percent of the Panel accepted this sentence in our 2017 survey. See Usage Note at why.


题主的问题,只要看几句红的就行



请先 登录 后评论
  • 2 关注
  • 4 收藏,6753 浏览
  • WJRWX 提出于 2019-07-12 17:12

相似问题