2 关于状语从句中(特别是where)的四个问题

曹老师您好:十分感谢您对:我之前的提问《状语从句中的从属关联词都叫什么名字(之前的统称叫从属连词是不正确的)》细致耐心的回答,谢谢您。

 

有和我类似问题困扰的学员请参考地址:http://ask.yygrammar.com/q-27083.html 

 

关于状语从句(名词性从句和定语从句用法“工整”规律性强,基本掌握,状语从句感觉“很散”,加上各种观点看法不一以及历史错误的“从属连词解读”的误导,脑子有点乱),关于状语从句我仍旧有如下困惑所以厚脸皮麻烦您在百忙之中给我指导以下的困惑点:

 

第一个问题:Where 引导的地点状语从句中,整个从句做主句的地点状语,那么where这个“从属关联词”,在从句中做不做成分?像定语从句一样做从句的地点状语吗?(毕竟where在名词性从句,定语从句都是表示地点的副词性质的引导词,都在上述两类从句中做地点状语,所以我想问状语从句中是否一样的规律)(有人说做,有人说不做,我个人老是感觉做)

例句如下:

1. You should have put the book where you found it.   (Where 是不是指代 found it ____ in the place?)

2. Where they went, there they were warmly welcomed. (Where 是不是指代 go ____ to the place?)

3. Keep it where you see it (和1. 一样吗?)

 

第二个问题:

A问:第二个问题是承接第一个问题来的,如果第二个问题答案是肯定的,做地点状语。但是如下例句有感觉不是做地点状语的。

1. There is only a vacant lot where her house used to be. (作表语?)

2. Just stay where you are. (…are ____ in the place? 也做表语?)

B问:如果这个作表语,那么对应当定语从句出现这种后缀修饰先行词时候,是不是也是做表语?属于少的个别情况?

C问:请看如下两个例句:

1.That is where my mother usually is at this time of a day.这个表语从句中where也做usually is 的表语吗?

2. Do you know where my bike is? 宾语从句中where也是做了表语吗?

 

第三个问题:地点状语从句中的引导词有 where,wherever, anywhere, everywhere.

wherever, anywhere, everywhere从句做什么成分我彻底乱成一锅粥了,请看下面例句:

1. You can sit wherever you like. (做like的宾语?)

2. Anywhere she goes, he goes too. (不知道做什么成分)

3. Everywhere I go, I find the same thing. (不知道做什么成分)

4. Wherever I am, I will be thinking of you. (也不清楚)

 

第四个问题:时间状语从句例句如:

The children ran away from the orchard, the moment the saw the guard.

While John was watching TV, his wife was cooking.

When 和 where 应该是类似的,定语从句中。但是在状语从句中我老是感觉when 和 if , because 等从属连词一样,只是引导两个完整不缺成分的主从句并赋予一个逻辑关系罢了,并没有“语感(可能是错误的)”说when 在从句中也做时间状语(像定语从句),但是where呢?恰恰相反,总是“感觉”(可能是错误的)做从句的状语。 这样一来,when 和where 在状语从句中不一致了,我就二糊了。

这俩到底什么关系呢?when做不做从句的时间状语呢?


请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2018-05-24 10:57


第一个问题

传统语法认为引导引导地点状语从句的where是个连词。但实际上根据传统语法对连词的定义---不作分句成分,通过分析我们就可以知道其实where在引导地点状语从句时在从句中是作了成分的,where在从句中作地点状语或表语(地点副词可以作表语)。Huddleston在The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language一书中 (P1068)也指出,where和wherever都是融合型关系词,where和wherever引导的状语从句在该书中被分析为关系分句,认为这种状语从句等于一个介词短语+限制性定语从句。例如:

We must put it where no one will be able to see it.

= We must put it in a place where no one will be able to see it.

即where=in a place where, 介词+place+关系副词where融合为一个副词where,我们称之为融合型关系副词,引导副词性关系分句作状语。


You should have put the book where you found it.   (Where =in the place where)

=You should have put the book in the place where you found it.

Where they went, they were warmly welcomed. (Where =in every place where)

=In every place where they went, they were warmly welcomed.

Keep it where you see it (和1. 一样.)

=Keep it in the place where you see it.

可以看出,以上几个句子中where除了引导地点状语从句外,同时还在从句中作地点状语。

 

第二个问题:

A:where不仅可以在从句中作状语,还可以作表语。

There is only a vacant lot where her house used to be. (where在从句中作表语)

=There is only a vacnat lot in the place where her house used to be.

Just stay where you are. (where在从句中表语)

=Just stay in the place where you are.

B:融合型关系副词还可以引导名词性从句,此时where=the place where. 即where从句相当于一个地点名词后接限制性定语从句

C:

That is where my mother usually is at this time of a day.这个表语从句中where为融合型关系副词,作从句 的表语。

=That is the place where my mother ususally is at this time of a day.

Do you know where my bike is? 此句中的where为疑问副词,引导宾语从句,where在从句中作表语

 

第三个问题:地点状语从句中的引导词有 where,wherever, anywhere, everywhere.

wherever, anywhere, everywhere从句做什么成分我彻底乱成一锅粥了,请看下面例句:

You can sit wherever you like. (like后省略了不定式to sit)

= You can sit in any place where you like to sit. where在从句中作to sit的状语。

Anywhere she goes, he goes too. (anywhere在从句中作地点状语)

=To any place where she goes, he goes too.

=He goes to any place where she goes.

Everywhere I go, I find the same thing. (everywhere在从句中作地点状语)

=In every place where I go, I find the same thing.

=I find the same thing in every place where I go.

Wherever I am, I will be thinking of you. wherever引导的是让步状语从句,不是地点状语从句。wherever=no matter where)

=No matter where I am, I will be thinking of you.

 

第四个问题:时间状语从句例句如:

The children ran away from the orchard the moment they saw the guard.

=The children ran away from the orchard at the moment when they saw the guard.

While John was watching TV, his wife was cooking.

=During the time when John was watching TV, his wife was cooking.

When 和 where确实是类似的。区别在于where在从句中通常作必具性状语,即没有这个状语从句的意思就不完整。where还可在从句中作表语,没有表语的话从句显然结构都是不完整的。但when在从句中通常作修饰性状语,修饰性状语不影响分句结构的完整,故给人的感觉是when没有在从句中作成分。


不过,绝大多数的语法书和词典都将引导状语从句的where和when当作连词对待。除了where在从句中作表语用连词无法合理解释外,其它情况按照连词解释似乎也能讲得通。认为where,when在从句中作状语因而应该是副词是极少数人的观点。在这一点上,你最好随大流,以避免无谓的争论。


请先 登录 后评论

其它 0 个回答

相似问题