1 定语从句中which能否指代状语从句

Since adults know how to place the key in the slot, which is the ultimate purpose of approaching the slot. 

 

请教老师,which的先行词或句子是谁?which可以指代状语从句吗?比如本句中which是否指代“Since adults know how to place the key in the slot”?

谢谢老师们。

请先 登录 后评论

最佳答案 2018-03-05 14:54

网友提问时应该提供完整的句子,这只是一个状语从句和一个非限制性定语从句,缺少主句。

which从句不是修饰状语从句,而是修饰不定式to place the key in the slot. which的先行项可以是前面的整个分句,也可以是分句的一部分,包括不定式。传统语法称之为非限制性定语从句确实欠妥。现代语法称为关系分句,作补充性状语。

从逻辑上讲,接近钥匙孔的目的是将钥匙插入钥匙孔,因此which指代的是to place the key in the slot, 而不是整个分句。

请先 登录 后评论

其它 1 个回答

刘永科   - 教育出版集团英语总顾问 & 英语系列图书主编
擅长:语法理论,语言学,文化背景


我查阅了原文的出处,完整的句子是这样的:

Since adults know how to place the key in the slot, which is the ultimate purpose of approaching the slot, and since the child is neither old enough nor clever enough to realize the desired action on his own, what possible gain is achieved by having his struggle? 

【翻译】由于大人们知道如何将钥匙放到钥匙槽中这样做是接近钥匙槽的最终目的,又由于小孩子既不够成熟也不够聪明,自己无法完成这个要求的动作,那么,他的努力又能得到什么收获呢?

【分析】我认为,which 既不是指代整个主句,也不是指代某一个单词(the key或the slot),而是指代整个how to place the key in the slot(= the way to place the key in the slot 将钥匙放到钥匙槽中的方法)。所以,把which 翻译成“这样做”。

which引导非限制性定语从句时,有一个特殊的用法,就是:它除了指代主句中的某个名词或者整个主句的内容外,还可以指代主句中的某个名词词组(how to do sth. 也属于名词性词组)、形容词或形容词短语。例如:

The man was unable to earn enough money, which allowed him to support his family.

那人无法赚到足够的钱,只有足够的钱才能让他得以养活家人。

which 指代enough money,不是单个的money。更不是整个主句:整个主句的意思是“无法赚到足够的钱”,既然赚不到钱,怎么养活家人?

又如:

1. He was not sick, which some of the other passengers were.

他没有生病,但有些其他旅客却病了。

(which指代形容词sick)

2. She is always careless, which we should not be.

她总是马虎大意,我们可不应该这样。

(which指代形容词careless)

3. The two policemen were completely trusted, which in fact they were.

那两个警察完全受到信任,事实上,也真是如此。

(which指代形容词短语completely trusted)

4. She was very patient towards the children, which her husband seldom was.  

她对孩子们很耐心,她丈夫却很少这样。 

(which指代形容词短语patient towards the children)

 

 

 


请先 登录 后评论
  • 0 关注
  • 2 收藏,9921 浏览
  • cici 提出于 2018-02-26 23:01

相似问题