原句:This will lead to a far greater diversity of urban landscape designs than are apparent today.
参考翻译:这将带来远远丰富于今日的城市景观多样性。
疑问:原句中“than”后面有没有省略了什么成分呢?为什么是“than are apparent”这么奇怪的结构?如果句子是:This will lead to a far greater diversity of urban landscape designs than they have/are apparently today. 这句话就好理解了。还望老师赐教。
This will lead to a far greater diversity of urban landscape designs than are apparent today.
按照Huddleston CGEL的解释,主句的比较项a far greater diversity of urban landscape designs的对应项在比较分句中作主语,则这个主语必须省略,主语的位置形成一个空缺(gap). 即than从句是一个缺少主语的不完整的分句。即主句表示的未来更为多样化的都是景观设计和现在显而易见的都市景观设计进行比较,而现在的城市景观设计是比较的对应项,必须在than从句中省去。
也有人认为,than表示比较意义,同时替代了主句比较项中的名词the urban landscape designs, 并在从句中作主语。than可用compared with the urban landscape designs that。例如:
This will lead to a far greater diversity of urban landscape designs compared with the urban landscape designs that are apparent today.
如果觉得我的回答对您有用,请随意打赏。你的支持将鼓励我继续创作!
同意曹老师的解答,但我有一个疑问。
我经常看到曹老师这样注解than 及其后面的意思:
This will lead to a far greater diversity of urban landscape designs compared with the urban landscape designs that are apparent today.
据我所知,过去分词短语compared with 虽然表示比较意义,但句中不需出现比较级形式,也就是说,不需出现-er 或more 的字眼。例如:
This is fearfully expensive compared with the last one I bought.
这和我上次买的相比贵得吓人。
来自柯林斯例句
The room was light and lofty compared with our Tudor ones.
跟我们都铎风格的房间比起来,这个房间显得素雅而大气。
来自柯林斯例句
Life was now drab compared with the more exciting life style overseas.
比起海外那种更富有刺激的生活方式来,现在的生活显得了无生气。
来自《简明英汉词典》
我的疑问是:
这是不是Huddleston CGEL 的解释?
在有比较级的情况下,compared with 能否取代than?
如果觉得我的回答对您有用,请随意打赏。你的支持将鼓励我继续创作!
This will lead to a far greater diversity of urban landscape designs than are apparent today.
参考翻译:这将产生一个远远丰富于今日显而易见的的城市景观设计多样性。
解答如下:
比较对象为“diversity of urban landscape”从句不可以在加主语,从句主语空缺位被than填充
greater diversity of urban landscape designs 与many diversity of urban landscape design 进行比较
从句从比较连接代词取代了many diversity of urban landscape designs
备注:同意刘老师,compared with A, B do sth, B分句不需要用比较级形式
Compared with French,English is easy.
=When English is compared with French, it is easy.
英语比法语好学/与法语相比,英语容易学。
Compared with what he had already, the new stamps were not very interesting.
跟他已有的相比,这几张新邮票算不上有趣。
如果觉得我的回答对您有用,请随意打赏。你的支持将鼓励我继续创作!